A View of Reviews

I recently read, on a couple different sources, that there is a “campaign”, by people who are upset that the new/final Robert Jordan book is not going to be immediately released as an e-book, to give the story a bunch of “one-star” reviews on Amazon. They are, apparently, hoping the “campaign” will either sewer the sales of the book, or bully the publisher into releasing the book digitally.

To this I must say: “Get your collective heads out of your asses.”

In my mind reviews serve a distinct and important function. They exist so that people can get an idea of how other readers feel about a book, so they can decide whether or not they want to spend their hard earned money on a story. They do not exist so that a group of people can complain that the book is not available in the format they prefer.

For the writer, reviews grow ever more important the closer you are to the beginning of your writing career. For someone like me, who is getting their work into the market for the first time, a positive review is a validation that someone likes our work and we’re doing something right. A negative review, as long as it isn’t filled with pure hate and venom, might give us an idea of something we’re falling short on, or missing in our writing (of course, we also might choose to completely disregard the negative review and focus on the positive, which I don’t think is a bad thing either).

When I get a review (and I’ve got all of 7 on Amazon.com), I like to see what the reader thought, and how, if at all, my story affected them. It is extremely gratifying when someone enjoys my story, and lets me know about it. It makes my day. It motivates me to keep writing. Even if someone contacts me, either through a review or via the email on my website, and tells me my book is shit, at least I know someone besides my Dad has read it.

I really do think that reviews can be a valuable thing, if used in the right spirit. But to throw out negative reviews, without ever having read the book, is just ignorant, and a little silly.

It is unlikely that most of us will come face to face with the author of a book we particularly liked, but it can be a meaningful medium of communication to post a review of a book where the author is likely to see it. It can be a big deal, especially to some unknown tool like me.

So, if you like a book that took someone three years to write and find a publisher for, then it would be awfully cool if you took 5 minutes of your time to share some of your thoughts. It will serve the writer, and other readers as well.

Thanks for reading.



Filed under Uncategorized

6 responses to “A View of Reviews

  1. It would be good if your could list your sources so we can leave comments on their blogs or whatever to express our disdain for their tactics. Good blog!

  2. katyasozaeva

    This has been going on for ages. People are completely unethical if they can do things anonymously (like downvote reviews, or rate negatively). People who negatively rate books based upon rumors or any reason other than they read and hated the book just drive me nuts! Thanks for taking a stand about this!

  3. I review books, twice a week, on my blog and commercial / book sites. I simply cannot imagine reviewing something I haven’t read or making negative posts just to punish/influence a publisher. How ridiculous.

    Worse than giving 5-star ratings to crappy books – which I also don’t understand.

  4. Eleanor

    Tyner, I work with Lara who put me on to your book “The Watch”. I got it for Christmas and really enjoyed it. I was on the edge of my seat a few times. I am looking forward to your next project as I found your writing easy to understand but with a bit of suspence that kept me wanting to read more. Keep it up. I don’t believe in giving a review of something I personally haven’t experienced so I can honestly say, The Watch is worth reading.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s